We Make Insurance Easy.

Auto - Home - Business - Life - Health

Selling insurance in NOrtheast Ohio since 1971.


Need a quote?


The insurance world is full of choices in coverage before you even entertain all the different policies available from different companies.

Fill in the below and someone will get back to you right away:

Name *
Phone *
(not required)
What coverages do you need? *
(Check all that apply.)
Do you have insurance right now? *

Service Request

Did you get a new car? Did you get a new roof? Need to put your convertible in storage for the winter? Send us as much information as possible below and we'll work on it right away. This form will get the process started and we will confirm with you when it's complete. 

Note: Insurance coverage cannot be added, deleted or otherwise changed by voicemail or email without confirmation by Lyndall Associates, Inc. or your insurance carrier.

Phone: 440-247-3750
Fax: 440-247-3720

You can also send us a message below. 

Name *
What kind of policy does this relate to?
Check all that apply.

 Our Offices

Lyndall Insurance Chagrin Falls

7227 Chagrin Road
Chagrin Falls, OH 44023


Connerton-Feran Eastlake

35728 Vine St.
Eastlake, OH 44095


We’re a family-owned independent insurance agency serving Northeast Ohio.

As a family-owned agency with deep Northeast Ohio roots, we aim to give the same personal service to you that we’d give to our own families.

Whether insuring your car, your home, or your business, we’ll work hard to analyze and understand every factor that could affect your coverage and rates.

(440) 247-3750

7227 Chagrin Road
Chagrin Falls, OH 44023


The Lyndall Insurance Team

dale lyndall headshot.jpg

Dale Lyndall (Owner/principal)

Dale started our agency in 1971 from scratch. Since that time, the agency has grown to represent countless Northeast Ohio families, as well as a commercial customer base spanning industries big and small.

Donald Connerton, Andrea Picklesimer, and Craig Lyndall (2019)

Donald Connerton, Andrea Picklesimer, and Craig Lyndall (2019)

In January 2019, Connerton-Feran in Eastlake, Ohio joined the Lyndall Insurance team. Principal Donald Connerton and service agent Andrea Picklesimer continue with the team today.

Get a quote from Connerton-Feran

mark lyndall headshot.jpg

Mark Lyndall (Owner/principal)

Mark joined the agency in 2006 after spending two years learning the insurance business as a claims adjuster. He got his business degree at Monmouth University in New Jersey.

Bill Davis of AR Davis Insurance in Newbury

Bill Davis of AR Davis Insurance in Newbury

In October 2016, Bill Davis and the AR Davis Insurance agency joined Lyndall Insurance. Bill and Gloria Suchy stayed on, while Lindsey Emery joined them from the Lyndall team in Chagrin Falls.

Get a Quote from
AR Davis

Craig Lyndall.jpg

craig Lyndall (Owner/principal)

Craig joined the agency in 2007 following five years working and learning in the corporate world. He has a BS in business from Boston University.

Located in South Euclid Ohio

Located in South Euclid Ohio

Virgil E. Brown Insurance joined the team back in the early 2000’s. Darlene Threat and Stan Collins have been helping clients for two decades.

Get a Quote from Virgil Brown

What do I do if I have a claim?

One of the most confusing times for our clients is when there's a claim. You've had an auto accident or something has happened that has damaged your home. What do you do? Who do you call? Hopefully this page will help.

Contact info for your company is on this page. Additionally, you can email us a question with the contact form below or always call us during business hours. 


Do I have a claim?

If you have this question, your first call should be to us at Lyndall Insurance. You can call us during our business hours or send an email using the form below. We will discuss the incident and help you figure out if you have a claim or not. If there's any question, it's likely worth having a discussion.

How do I file a claim?

Claims are handled by the insurance companies themselves. They adjust the claims and write checks to cover the losses. If you have a claim, your first step is to call the claims number for the carrier your insurance is with.

What happens after a file a claim?

The insurance company will assign an adjuster who will manage the process of studying the incident, finding what coverage is applicable and settling the claim with you for the appropriate amount of money.

If at any point during this process, you have questions or concerns, it is our job at Lyndall Insurance to be your guide and advocate. We represent you and will help you ensure the company is meeting appropriate expectations.

Do I need a police report?

It's always better to have official documentation.

I got into a car accident that isn't my fault

If there's an accident that isn't your fault, ideally you can settle the claim with that other company directly. This takes a bit of work and patience, but it helps keep your own insurance claims history clean. Lyndall Insurance can help guide you through this process and if it becomes too difficult or too much trouble, you can file with your own carrier, pay your own deductible and your company will subrogate after the fact.

For example, if you are insured with Grange and the person at fault is insured with Allstate, you can file your auto claim with Grange, and Grange will take care of you and later try and get compensated by Allstate. 

What is a deductible?

The deductible is the financial portion of the loss you're taking on personally. Typically auto deductibles are between $250 and $1000. If you have a $5000 claim and a $500 deductible, your settlement will be $4500.

Do I have rental car coverage?

Most auto policies sold by Lyndall Insurance have rental coverage, but occasionally clients decline it or ask us to remove it. You'll have to refer to your policy or ask us to refer to your policy to be sure. 

I have an injury. When should I settle?

This is a really tough question. Generically speaking, you don't want to settle until after you're medical treatment related to an accident is 100% complete. When it comes to situations like these, we generally defer to doctors and the client themselves. Occasionally, clients decide to use attorneys. We defer there as well. We are licensed insurance people, but when it comes to situations involving medical expertise all we can do is offer to give you insight into prior experiences as an agency.

Name *

Company Claims Contact Info:

Acuity Insurance:

  • Claims 800-242-7666

  • Glass 866-815-7696

  • Towing 866-732-1466

  • Email:

Auto-Owners Insurance:

  • Claims 888-857-7914

  • Glass 800-264-4143

  • Towing 888-869-2642

Chubb Insurance:

  • Claims 800-252-4670

  • Glass 800-252-4670

  • Towing 800-252-4670

Erie Insurance

  • Claims 800-362-6541

  • Glass 800-552-3743

  • Towing 888-295-5060

Grange Insurance:

  • Claims 800-445-3030

  • Glass 800-951-9734

  • Towing 800-837-5570

  • Email


  • Claims 800-922-4050

  • Glass 800-922-4050

  • Towing 888-310-8020

  • Email

Motorists Mutual:

  • Claims 800-876-2538

  • Glass 877-379-4669

  • Towing 800-876-2538

  • Email


  • Claims 800-274-4499

  • Glass 800-274-4499

  • Towing 800-776-2778


  • Claims 800-252-4633

  • Glass 800-252-4633

  • Towing 800-252-4633

Westfield Group:

  • Claims 866-937-2663

  • Glass 800-810-3665

  • Towing 800-787-9078

  • Email


7227 Chagrin Road
Chagrin Falls, OH, 44023
United States


 NEW! Click Here to Register for the Client Portal

Click the registration option and use the email we have on file at our agency.